Worldy shunning......what an interesting idea! Hang on shunning has been going on for centuries in all forms. Look at the Jews.
On what grounds are you refering to worldy shunning. Religious? Human nature? Political? Culture? Race? To wrap them all up together is a little closed mined.
Religious shunning can happen in almost any religion, using the same line the GB use for their reason. Look at the protestants and catholics in norther ireland, ok that ones got political overtones it in it as well. Some christian faiths have a edict to shun those who reject their faith or policies. (gays in the catholic church iirc). Is this not the same as JW? What makes your shunning right and theirs wrong?
Lets look at human nature? Sometimes shunning is a good thing. A destructive relationship, abusive family. The disconnection from this is not a bad thing. Sometimes it is the only thing. Maybe they will change? then again Maybe not. But putting rule in place to govern the reinstatment would be silly. Each person has to think for themself and decide by their own choice of if they should associate with that person.
Shunning on a political basis, race or cultural is rampant. To say it wasn't would be silly. All around you it is happening! The rules that cause the shunning are no different to those of the WBTS. You disagree on a belief or viewpoint of mine and thus I am going to cut you out.
A white girl goes out with a black guy and the dad kicks her out, shuns her because of his belief that she shouldn't go with a black guy.
Is he right? The black guy could be the nicest bloke in the world and love his daughter but because he disagreed with his belief he shuns her.
Sound familar? Whats the difference between this and someone saying that they don't believe in the truth and getting shunned.
Nothing.
So what if she decides that the black guy is the wrong guy and a bad for her. In the GB world she would then have to prove her dedication. Lets put it in the case of the white girl. What would she have to do? Date a Klan member or how about a far right fascist to prove her beliefs?
Does this really solve the emotional hurt, in the example should the dad behave as if nothing has happened as the daughter has met the rules for re-instatment?
Would it not be better for the father to unconditionally love his daughter? Tell her that her actions hurt her but he loves her all the same.
When someone is reinstated in the JW does everyone behave to them like nothing happened? What happens to the hurt or anger those people felt when they were left or abandoned? be it from either side? Or do they behave as if nothing happened because the elder said they were okay now?
Shunning is a tool that has been around for YEARS for people to control people! Rules or no rules, it has been there since the begining and it is here now and as wrong now as it was then.
Did Jesus shun anyone?
Think about this:
You will never agree with everyone, period
There will always be some people you get on with and others you don't
Just because someone has a different belief or view point, doesn't make them a bad person that you should have nothing to do with.
Everyone is entitled to a view point and a feeling
Others shouldn't force their view point on others.